早在上星期四(9/7)，【殺人犯】上畫當天，我就有睇哂yahoo電影的觀眾意見，有大部份是睇過首映的人留言，其中有部份人只比一粒星，對劇情好不滿，但係5粒星的大有人在。
上星期五睇完電影後，在星期六日再睇yahoo電影評分就出現一些奇怪現象，即日一粒星的comment仍在，而對上幾天見過一粒星的comment不見了，剩下的大部份是5粒星，明明星期日見過有過300+評論，總分是3粒星，今早又變回270+，去番4星半，而我在今天的評論中找到部份比一粒星的觀眾都有同一樣的疑問，我相信yahoo不會無啦啦delete影評，而隔離【再生號】咁，亦只是一面倒的一粒星，又話比人delete了一些較高分的comment，究竟背後做了什麼呢?
其實想問...點解d 對呢套片壞的comment 去左邊..
明明今日去到29x 幾個....點解而家又變左240 個comment..
係d人delet ... 其實想問...點解d 對呢套片壞的comment 去左邊..
明明今日去到29x 幾個....點解而家又變左240 個comment..
係d人delet 一星的comment??
or delet d 講左結局的comment 呢???
令到套戲而家有4.5 星...for me ...it is not worth 4.5 星..所以要拉低返！
http://hk.movies.yahoo.com/movie_rep.html?id=mcl_murderer&t=details&rid=673
當全世界的留言板都係負面意見, yahoo的留言大部分係五粒星, 呢個世界真係黑暗, 請yahoo自重, 唔好再delete neg comments, 否則無人再用yahoo
http://hk.movies.yahoo.com/movie_rep.html?id=mcl_murderer&t=details&rid=694
由開頭到中間都覺得唔錯，ARRON做得都幾好...
不過一知道左既ENDING，即時深吸一口大氣想爆X...
點解而家電影圈D編劇可以差成咁？浪費左成班好演員。
仲有，我好懷疑YAHOO影評既可信性，我見到好多比''差''既COMMENT比人DELETE左，係咪有人有心咁做架？
http://hk.movies.yahoo.com/movie_rep.html?id=mcl_murderer&t=details&rid=673
唔知點解我之前用第2個acc留果個言冇左
之後諗住留多次,佢唔比我留!
係咪block左我果個acc請問?
我又冇打粗口,只係講出我個睇完既感受,點解要del?真係百思不得其解!
仲有,,果d 5星係假ga!一睇就知!
有咩理由成甘多板都係5星??
果d算咩影評!根本就係做馬!
套野果ending根本就係唔好
又唔接受事實,呢個影評開黎做乜?
First, I just used my old account to write one more comment, I just discover I have similar experience as another user. Yahoo doesn't allow me to post comment (maybe because I rate only 2 stars for this movie). This comment is not for the movie as it is already the worst movie of the year and the worst movie I've ever seen.
But what I really want to write is ... I watched this movie last week and I wrote a comment immediately, and on that day, I saw there're a lot of bad 1 star comments since last week. However, its all gone now. And also, those who left bad comment are not allowed to comment again. You can see there're 20+ pages continuous with 5 stars comments. I won't surprise this is just a channel of promotion of the movie, but what surprise me is .... Yahoo, which is the most reputable brand in the world, Why? Do you still want to keep your brand and goodwill ?????
http://hk.movies.yahoo.com/movie_rep.html?id=mcl_murderer&t=details&rid=738
First, this movie is not worth 4.5 stars. Definitely the movie is not good. But what makes public angry is I suspect Yahoo DELETED all of the negative comments since last week. We can only see negative comments from Jul 13, 2009. You couldn't find any negative comment before Jul 13. Is it really nobody posted bad comments before Jul 13? Please think !!!
http://hk.movies.yahoo.com/movie_rep.html?id=mcl_murderer&t=details&rid=741
其實喜歡與不喜歡是很主觀的，不用互相攻擊，若然真的刻意delete一些差的電影評論為了增加分數，則未免小家了一點了。
我發覺不同電影亦有delete評論的現象, 有些電影是只delete高分的評論, 真的很奇怪, 究竟yahoo發生什麼事?
以下是2009年7月14日, 19:09, 最新的電影評論
http://hk.movies.yahoo.com/movie_rep.html?id=mcl_murderer&t=details&rid=822
若根據這條link最後的數字來計評論人數(每一條link都有一個順序的number), 即822個評論, 而現在只有308個comment, 餘下的514個評論去了那處?
2 則留言:
我好耐以前已經懷疑Yahoo影評既可信性, 好似當年"Golden Compass(魔幻羅盤)", 影評平均都有四粒星以上, 點知這電影故事爛到離奇, 對冇睇過原著的人一定會睇到一頭霧水! 這電影原本和Lord of the Ring般有幾集, 但事實上票房差到爛尾收場, 不會再拍第二, 三部. 四粒星? 真係得啖笑, 我從此唔再信Yahoo影評.
[版主回覆07/14/2009 19:07:00]
yahoo真係好差囉, 我見佢地今日又delete哂尋日果d一星comment, 平均去到4星半, 好在我copy左條link, 可以睇得番, 如果正常途徑去佢個版面就冇哂我post果d意見哪! 同埋呢套戲好唔好睇見人見智, 不過我唔相信有咁多5星囉, 連3,4星都唔多, 真係好假!至伊家有308comment, 15個一粒星, 睇下聽日又變成點!
http://hk.movies.yahoo.com/movie_rep.html?id=mcl_murderer
有人寫左以下影評: " 演員一流, 編劇九流 !", 然後俾足五粒星 !? ....Yahoo Movie真係算吧啦.
[版主回覆07/15/2009 18:21:00]yeah, 真係唔值得信
發佈留言